Top 5 Best Burgers in Binghamton, New York: Where to Sink Your Teeth In
- Yaron Kweller
- Feb 19
- 3 min read
Binghamton might be famous for spiedies, but the burger scene here is seriously underrated. From no-frills dive bars slinging massive Angus patties to craft spots with creative toppings, the Triple Cities deliver juicy, flavor-packed burgers that’ll make you forget about chain restaurants.
Ron Kweller ranked my personal Top 5 based on taste, value, atmosphere, and that perfect char-to-juiciness ratio. Number one? A downtown sports bar stealing the show with an unbeatable weekly deal. Let’s dig in!
Location: 56-58 Court Street, Binghamton, NY 13901
Why it’s #1: Hand-crafted smash-style burgers in a lively sports bar setting, plus the legendary $5 Burger Tuesday that has locals lining up. The classic Courtside Burger (double smash patty, melty cheese, fresh toppings) is a steal at five bucks—perfectly seasoned, crispy edges, and juicy inside. Specialty burgers (Western, Beer Cheese, etc.) jump to just $7 on Tuesdays too.
It’s the ultimate deal for big flavor without breaking the bank, and the vibe is pure fun—big screens, cold beers, and that downtown energy.
Pro tip: Go on Tuesday, grab a domestic draft, and thank me later.
Website: courtsidebing.com
2. The Belmar Pub & Grill (The Legendary Dive-Bar Beast)
Location: 95 Main Street, Binghamton, NY 13905
Why it’s #2: Half-pound certified Angus beef patties that are grilled to perfection in a classic no-frills West Side pub. The signature Belmar Burger (seasoned patty, lettuce, tomato, red onion, mayo) is simple perfection, but the Black & Bleu (stuffed with bleu cheese, topped with bacon) or breakfast-style versions with egg and more bacon are life-changing.
It’s cheap, huge portions, and has that authentic neighborhood bar soul. Reviewers constantly call these “the best burgers I’ve ever had.”
Pro tip: Cash or card, but bring an appetite—these are massive.
3. The Shop (The Craft Burger King)
Location: 219 Washington Street, Binghamton, NY (heart of downtown)
Why it’s #3: Creative, high-quality burgers paired with an upscale-yet-cozy bar and brunch vibe. Standouts include the Bacon Brie Burger, truffle options, and perfectly seasoned patties on toasted buns. Everything feels elevated but still approachable, and the fries are next-level.
They do $15 Burgers & Champagne Fridays—yes, really. It’s the spot for a date night or weekend treat.
Pro tip: Check their Instagram (@theshop219) for daily specials and the full menu PDF. Website: theshop219.com
4. Fat Patties Burger Bar (The Portion Monster)
Location: 1123 Upper Front Street, Binghamton, NY
Why it’s #4: Fresh-to-order gourmet burgers with huge, creative builds and bar-food sides that could feed a small army. Favorites: El Diablo (spicy heat), The Fat Pattie classic loaded up, or stacked chicken options if you’re feeling wild. Everything is cooked fresh, portions are ridiculous, and the flavors pop.
Locals swear by it for bar nights or takeout.
Pro tip: Add those cheese fries or onion rings—you won’t regret it.
5. Lost Dog Cafe & Lounge (The Consistent Crowd-Pleaser)
Location: Downtown Binghamton (check Tripadvisor or Google for exact)
Why it’s #5: Consistently ranked at the very top of Binghamton burger lists on Tripadvisor for a reason—solid, flavorful burgers in a fun, eclectic lounge atmosphere. Great American classics with solid execution, plus a full bar and lively crowd. It’s the reliable spot that never disappoints.
Lost Dog Cafe (2026) - All You MUST Know Before You Go (with Reviews)
Pro tip: Pair it with their other bar bites for the full experience.
Final Thoughts
Binghamton’s burger game is strong, affordable, and full of character—from $5 Tuesdays at Courtside to half-pound legends at Belmar. Whether you’re a smash-burger purist, a topping maximalist, or just hunting for the best value, these five will not let you down.
Next time you’re in town, skip the drive-thru and hit one (or all) of these spots. Which one are you trying first? Drop your favorite Binghamton burger in the comments—I’m always up for adding to the list!
Hungry yet? Tag a friend and plan a burger crawl. Binghamton’s waiting. 🍔
(All photos sourced from restaurant sites, Uber Eats listings, Tripadvisor, and Yelp reviews as of 2026. Prices and hours can change—call ahead!)
Comments